Stacking Order

Technology and the Remaking of Global Interdependence

Luuk Schmitz

Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies

The puzzle

Trade volumes persist.
Supply chains span the globe.
Capital moves across borders.

Yet beneath this surface of continuity,
the architecture of interdependence
is being remade.

Core concept

What is a Stack?

stack /stæk/ n.

A vertically integrated system that bundles raw materials, manufacturing, software, and data infrastructure into a singular, non-interoperable architecture.

Following Benjamin Bratton's The Stack (2015): sovereignty is no longer only territorial but architectural — layered systems of computation and governance that cut across borders and redefine who controls what.

This book traces how stacks emerged not from grand strategy,
but from corporate planning routines at the technological frontier.

The old world

The Ethereal Economy

The dominant image of successful capitalism carried an ethereal quality.

Apple designs in California Foxconn assembles in Shenzhen Value captured through IP

Physical assets were liabilities. Manufacturing was modular.
Suppliers were interchangeable. Interfaces made it all work.

Modular hierarchy

Traditional supply chain: OEM atop modular supplier pyramid

The OEM pyramid: legible interfaces, interchangeable suppliers, value captured at the top.

The collapse of modularity

The Physics Strike Back

EVs were supposed to be more modular than combustion engines.
Instead, the empirical evidence showed the opposite.

Battery chemistry cannot be optimized independently from thermal management,
which cannot be optimized independently from vehicle structure,
which cannot be optimized independently from software.

To beat the physics, firms had to beat the market
internalizing coordination that arm's-length
transactions cannot provide.

Two responses

The Bifurcation

Supply chain bifurcation: Architectural Control vs Architectural Interdependence

Architectural control (eliminate interfaces entirely) vs. Architectural interdependence (colonize the interface)

What this looks like

Two Worlds

VW supply chain network

Volkswagen Group
1,400+ entities · 40+ countries

BYD supply chain network

BYD
~170 entities · China-centric

The macro-expansion

From Engineering to Statecraft

Firms solved control in a fragmented world.
States nationalized the solution.

🇺🇸 Conditional Access

Market-emergent stacks harnessed by the state

Architectural conditionality: reconfigure your infrastructure as the price of admission

G42 stripped $2B of Huawei equipment to access the American AI stack

vs.

🇨🇳 Outward Projection

State-incubated stacks projected abroad

Alignment through accumulated integration: workforce skills, tooling, software ecosystems

$200B+ manufacturing FDI since 2019 — exceeding the Marshall Plan

The concept

Stacked Interdependence

Not weaponized interdependence — exploiting existing network nodes.
Not decoupling — severing flows.

Stacked interdependence

A configuration in which control over multiple layers of a vertically integrated production system forecloses the possibility of exit. Power derives not from controlling a single chokepoint, but from the depth of integration across the stack.

Key insight: The features designed for profit — lock-in, high switching costs, ecosystem dominance — serve equally well as templates for long-term geopolitical alignment.

The stakes

Localization ≠ Sovereignty

CATL battery stack with host states and automakers

Resource states (Bolivia, DRC):
control extraction, but depend on CATL's downstream processing to realize value.

European hosts (Germany, Hungary):
have gigafactories — but depend on upstream materials beyond their regulatory reach.

Automakers (BMW, VW):
even cell-only contracts inherit hidden dependencies on proprietary software & raw materials.

Control at one layer does not translate into autonomy across the stack.

Where stacks collide

Europe: A Model in Crisis

The October 2024 EV tariff vote — a referendum on Europe's position in the emerging order.

For tariffs
France, Italy, Poland, Netherlands, Baltics, Nordics
Less integrated into Chinese stacks
Against tariffs
Germany, Hungary, Malta, Slovenia, Slovakia
Deep stack integration with Chinese architecture
Abstained
Spain, Belgium, Austria, much of Central Europe
Hedging between stacks

This pattern is illegible through standard EU cleavages — not North/South, not creditor/debtor.
It becomes legible only through stack exposure.

Defecting from a stack is not like renouncing an ideology.

It requires ripping out hardware, retraining engineers, and rebuilding systems at costs measured in billions of dollars and years of development time.

Where Cold War I offered entry through ideational conversion,
Cold War II forecloses exit through material integration.

Luuk Schmitz

luuk.schmitz@mpifg.de · Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies